When you avoid getting manuscript feedback prematurely, you protect your creative process and set yourself up for success. Writing a book is an exciting and deeply personal journey, but it’s also one that comes with its fair share of challenges. Along the way, many aspiring authors feel the urge to share their manuscripts with others—seeking feedback, validation, or encouragement. While this instinct is completely natural, sharing your work too soon can often do more harm than good. Understanding the potential risks of premature feedback and knowing how to navigate this stage wisely is crucial to staying on track and bringing your vision to life.
The Urge to Share Too Soon
I’ve seen it time and time again: authors with an incredible urge to share their manuscript in its early stages. Or sometimes people think “I’ve written a few chapters and sent it to ten people.” “I’ve drafted my manuscript and given it to my boss.” “I’ve asked my partner to read it.” While this might seem like a harmless or even helpful step, I believe it’s a dangerous move. Yes, “dangerous” is a strong word, but hear me out.
The Risk of Premature Feedback
Over the years, I’ve encountered countless authors who shared their manuscripts prematurely and received negative feedback that derailed their progress entirely. Why? Not everyone is good at giving feedback. They might not understand your ideal reader. The person you ask for feedback might not grasp what you’re trying to achieve. They might not see the essence of what you’re writing. Worse still, they often view your manuscript through their personal lens, which can result in unhelpful or even harmful comments.
Not Everyone Wants to See You Succeed
This is the darker side of seeking feedback. Unfortunately, not everyone will cheer you on. Some people feel threatened or challenged by the idea of you writing a book. I’ve seen relationships strained because a partner offered feedback that was more personal than professional. This kind of unwarranted negativity can crush an author’s confidence and lead to a manuscript being abandoned altogether.
Protecting Your Manuscript
If you do decide to seek feedback, here’s how to do it wisely:
- Be Selective: Show your manuscript only to people you trust and who understand your vision.
- Provide Context: Share your book pitch, including details about your ideal reader, central question, and unique angle. This helps them understand your purpose.
- Set Boundaries: Be clear about the type of feedback you’re seeking. Avoid vague comments like, “This is great.” Instead, ask specific questions:
- Does it sound like me?
- Is it clear and engaging?
- Does it answer the right questions?
- Does it reflect the tone I’m aiming for?
Remember, feedback should be constructive, actionable, and aligned with your goals.
Trust the Process
If you’re working with a team of professionals—book coaches, editors, or publishing experts—trust in their expertise. They understand your book, your audience, and your objectives. They’ll help you shape a manuscript that’s on track and ready for success.
Don’t Let Negativity Derail You – avoid getting manuscript feedback prematurely
It breaks my heart to see great books never come to life because of careless or ill-informed feedback. Writing a book is challenging enough without letting external voices throw you off course. Protect your mindset, focus on building great habits, and trust in your ability to write a world-class book.
